Medication Safety Assessment Tool
This tool helps you understand your medication safety risk and determine if you should get a brown bag medication review. Enter your medications below to assess your risk.
Enter Your Medications
Current Medications
Click "Add Medication" above to build your medication list
Imagine showing up to your doctorâs appointment with a brown paper bag full of pills, creams, vitamins, and herbal bottles. It might feel awkward. But this simple act could save your life. Thatâs the power of a brown bag medication review. Itâs not a fancy procedure. Itâs not high-tech. Itâs just you, your meds, and a healthcare provider who wants to make sure youâre not accidentally poisoning yourself.
Every year, tens of thousands of older adults end up in the hospital because of medication mistakes. Not because theyâre careless. But because theyâre taking too many pills, the wrong ones, or duplicates no one told them about. A 2023 study found that 68.3% of seniors who went through a brown bag review had at least one dangerous error caught - like taking two different blood pressure pills that cancel each other out, or mixing a sedative with an opioid that could stop their breathing.
What Exactly Is a Brown Bag Medication Review?
A brown bag medication review is when you bring every single thing you take - prescription, over-the-counter, vitamins, supplements, herbal drops, even that gummy you chew for joint pain - to your doctor or pharmacist. You put them all in a brown paper bag (hence the name) and let a trained professional go through them with you. No guesswork. No memory games. Just real bottles on the table.
This isnât new. It started in 1982 when pharmacists in the U.S. gave patients free brown bags to collect their meds before appointments. Back then, they noticed people couldnât remember what they were taking. One patient said he took "the blue one for his heart" - but had five blue pills. Another thought his "daily aspirin" was just for headaches, not realizing it was a blood thinner. The brown bag made it real.
Today, itâs part of standard care for seniors. Medicare Advantage plans now pay providers around $45.75 per review. Kaiser Permanente and Mayo Clinic require it for all patients over 65 during annual wellness visits. Why? Because when patients just list their meds verbally, only 13% of the list is accurate. With the brown bag? Accuracy jumps to 95%.
Why This Matters More Than You Think
Most people donât realize how many pills theyâre actually taking. A 2022 report found that 44.6% of adults over 65 take five or more medications - a condition called polypharmacy. That number climbs to 54.6% when you include OTC drugs and supplements. And hereâs the scary part: each extra pill increases your risk of a bad reaction.
One case from a Reddit thread in March 2024 tells the story. A 78-year-old woman was feeling dizzy and confused. Her family thought it was aging. But during a brown bag review, her pharmacist found she was taking three different sedatives - one from her primary care doctor, one from her cardiologist, and one from her sleep specialist. All prescribed legally. None of them knew about the others. The combination was enough to cause falls, memory loss, and even respiratory failure. Once she stopped two of them, her symptoms vanished.
Thatâs not rare. A 2016 study by Dr. Barry D. Weiss showed that brown bag reviews prevented hospitalizations in 12.7% of high-risk elderly patients. Thatâs nearly 1 in 8 people who avoided a trip to the ER just because someone looked at their actual pills.
What to Bring to Your Review
You donât need to be perfect. But you do need to bring everything. Hereâs the full list:
- All prescription medications - even ones you havenât taken in months
- All over-the-counter drugs - pain relievers, sleep aids, antacids, allergy pills
- All vitamins - multivitamins, vitamin D, B12, etc.
- All supplements - magnesium, fish oil, probiotics, turmeric capsules
- All herbal remedies - echinacea, ginkgo, garlic pills, melatonin
- All creams, patches, inhalers, eye drops, and liquid medicines
- The original containers - labels matter
- Any medication lists youâve written down - even if you think theyâre wrong
Donât leave anything out because you think itâs "not important." That gummy you take for arthritis? It can interact with blood thinners. That fish oil? It can raise bleeding risk if youâre on aspirin. The label says "take as needed"? Thatâs exactly why you need to bring it - your doctor needs to know how often youâre actually using it.
Pro tip: Donât just grab the bottles from your medicine cabinet. Go through your drawers, your purse, your nightstand. Many people forget meds they keep in different places. One patient in a 2023 survey said she forgot her insulin pens - and the whole review was useless.
What Happens During the Review
The review takes 30 to 45 minutes. Itâs not a quick check. The provider will:
- Compare every bottle to your medical records
- Look for duplicates - two pills with the same active ingredient
- Check for dangerous interactions - like mixing statins with grapefruit juice or blood thinners with NSAIDs
- Ask why youâre taking each one - many patients donât know
- Check expiration dates - old pills can be toxic or ineffective
- Assess if any meds are no longer needed
- Use the teach-back method: "Can you tell me in your own words why you take this?"
Theyâre not judging you. Theyâre not there to scold you for hoarding pills. Theyâre there to simplify your life. In the Bexley and Greenwich pilot study, 63.8% of participants had at least one unnecessary medication stopped after a review. Thatâs fewer pills, fewer side effects, and lower costs.
One woman, 82, was taking 14 pills a day. After the review, her doctor removed three that were no longer helping, stopped a duplicate blood pressure med, and replaced two with one combined pill. She went from 14 to 8. Her energy improved. Her dizziness went away. She said, "I didnât know I was taking so much of the same thing. I thought I was being careful."
Why Self-Reported Lists Fail
Most people think they can just write down their meds. But studies show thatâs not reliable. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) found that out of 10 to 15 patients who tried to list their meds from memory, only two got it right. Thatâs an 80-87% error rate.
Why? People forget. They donât remember names. They think "the blue pill" is the same as "the white pill with the 10 on it." They stop taking a med but never tell their doctor. They take a supplement because a friend said it helped, and never mention it.
Electronic lists arenât much better. A 2016 study showed theyâre only 45-60% accurate. Why? Because not all meds are in the system. OTC drugs, supplements, and herbal products rarely show up in EHRs. Thatâs why the physical bag is still the gold standard.
Common Problems and How to Avoid Them
Even with good intentions, things go wrong. Here are the top issues - and how to fix them:
- "I forgot my meds." Set a reminder on your phone a week before. Ask a family member to help you gather them. Keep a small bag in your car or by the door.
- "I didnât know I had to bring everything." Ask your clinic ahead of time. Most now send reminder cards or calls. If they donât, ask for a printed list of what to bring.
- "Iâm embarrassed I have so many pills." Youâre not alone. Most seniors do. The provider has seen this hundreds of times. No judgment. Just help.
- "I donât know why I take this." Thatâs okay. Thatâs why youâre there. Write down your questions. Bring them with you.
- "The review took too long." Yes, it does. But itâs worth it. Schedule it as a separate appointment, not squeezed into a 15-minute checkup.
One study found that reminding patients with a simple note - "Bring all your meds to your next visit to help us keep you safe" - increased compliance by 31.5%. Thatâs more effective than phone calls or posters.
What Comes After the Review
After the review, you should get a clear, updated list of what youâre taking - and why. It should include:
- Drug name (generic and brand)
- Dosage
- How often to take it
- Why youâre taking it
- Any changes - what was stopped, added, or switched
Ask for a printed copy. Save it. Show it to every new doctor. Keep it in your wallet or phone. Update it every time something changes.
Some clinics now use apps that scan pill bottles with your phone camera to match them to your records. Thatâs helpful - but it doesnât replace the brown bag. Why? Because 41.3% of errors involve meds that arenât in any electronic system - like supplements or leftover prescriptions.
Who Needs This Most
This isnât for everyone. But if you:
- Are 65 or older
- Take five or more medications
- See multiple doctors
- Have chronic conditions like diabetes, heart disease, or arthritis
- Have had a recent hospital stay or ER visit
- Feel more tired, dizzy, or confused than usual
Then you need this. The data is clear: 89.6% of adults over 65 take at least one medication. More than half take five or more. Thatâs a recipe for disaster if no oneâs checking.
Even if you think youâre doing fine - get a review. You might find youâre taking something you donât need anymore. Or youâre doubling up on a drug you forgot about. Or youâre mixing something that could cause a fall. All of that is fixable.
Whatâs Changing in 2025 and Beyond
Medicare is pushing hard for medication safety. By 2026, every Annual Wellness Visit will require a documented medication review. That means brown bag reviews are becoming mandatory, not optional.
Some pharmacies now offer free brown bag reviews. CVS Health runs a program called "Pharmacists Teach," where pharmacists sit down with patients, go through their meds, and even call their doctors to make changes. In pilot programs, adherence improved by 34.7%.
AI tools are being tested to scan pills and cross-check them with your health records - cutting review time by almost 20%. But experts warn: technology helps, but doesnât replace the human conversation. You still need to talk about why you take that supplement. You still need to hear, "You donât need this anymore." Thatâs the part no app can do.
Final Thought: Itâs Not About Pills. Itâs About Control.
Many seniors feel like their health is slipping away. Medications can make that worse - if theyâre out of control. A brown bag review puts you back in charge. Youâre not just taking pills. Youâre understanding them. Youâre asking questions. Youâre saying, "I deserve to know why Iâm taking this."
Itâs not about being perfect. Itâs about being safe. One bag. One appointment. One chance to get it right.
Do I need to bring every pill Iâve ever taken?
Yes - even if you havenât taken it in months. Your doctor needs to know whatâs in your system, what youâve tried, and what might still be lingering. Leftover antibiotics, old painkillers, or discontinued supplements can interact with your current meds. Bring everything youâve ever used, even if itâs expired or empty.
Can my pharmacist do this instead of my doctor?
Absolutely. Pharmacists are trained to spot drug interactions and unnecessary medications. Many pharmacies now offer free brown bag reviews. In fact, the American Pharmacists Association says pharmacists can reduce healthcare costs and prevent hospitalizations by doing these reviews - even if your doctor didnât request it. Ask your pharmacist if they offer this service.
What if I canât carry all my meds to the appointment?
Ask a family member, neighbor, or home care worker to help you gather and transport them. Some clinics will send a nurse to your home to do the review. Others will let you bring photos of the bottles - but this is less reliable. The best results come from seeing the actual bottles. If mobility is an issue, call ahead and ask about home visits or special arrangements.
Will my insurance cover this?
Yes - if youâre on Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, or certain private plans, brown bag reviews are often covered as part of preventive care. Many providers bill under medication therapy management (MTM) codes. Even if thereâs a small fee, itâs usually less than the cost of one preventable hospital stay. Ask your provider if the review is billable and what your out-of-pocket cost might be.
How often should I get a brown bag review?
At least once a year. But if youâve had a hospital stay, started or stopped a medication, or seen a new doctor, do it sooner. Medication changes are the most dangerous time. A 2023 study showed that 45% of medication errors happen within 30 days of a new prescription. Donât wait - schedule your review after any big change.
Comments (14)
Herman Rousseau
I used to think this was just a gimmick until my grandma did it. She was on 17 meds. Turns out she was taking two different versions of the same blood thinner. One was expired. The other was for her dog. đ¤Śââď¸ Sheâs now down to 6 and actually sleeps through the night. Bring the bag. No shame.
Johnnie R. Bailey
Thereâs a quiet poetry in the brown bag - itâs the physical manifestation of our fragmented healthcare. Each pill, each bottle, a fragment of a life lived under the weight of chronic illness, of specialists who never speak to each other. The bag doesnât judge. It just holds. And in holding, it heals.
Vikrant Sura
This is just another way for providers to bill Medicare. 45 bucks per review? Please. Most of these 'errors' are just patients taking supplements they *want* to take. Let people live their lives.
Ajay Brahmandam
I brought my bag to my pharmacist last month. He found three things I didnât even know I was still taking. One was from 2018. I thought Iâd stopped it. He laughed and said, 'Man, Iâve seen worse.' We tossed them. Felt lighter. Like decluttering your closet but for your insides.
Tarun Sharma
It is recommended that all patients over the age of 65 undergo a comprehensive medication reconciliation at least annually. This practice is supported by evidence from multiple peer-reviewed studies and is considered a standard of care in geriatric medicine.
Aliyu Sani
yo i been takin this ashwagandha for stress n my doc never asked bout it. then one day i got a bag fulla pills n he looked at it like i was a zombie. turns out it was messin with my BP med. now i just take it on weekends. peace.
Gabriella da Silva Mendes
Ugh. Another one of these âsenior safetyâ campaigns. Meanwhile, my cousin in Canada gets her meds delivered in blister packs with QR codes that auto-alert her doctor if she skips a dose. Weâre still using brown paper bags? In 2025? This is why Americaâs healthcare is stuck in 1998. #FirstWorldProblems
Jim Brown
The brown bag is not a procedure. It is a ritual. A sacred act of accountability between the self and the healer. In an age of digital abstraction, where prescriptions are rendered as data points, the physicality of the bottle - its weight, its label, its expiration date - restores the human dimension of care. We must not outsource our pharmacopeia to algorithms.
Sam Black
Iâve done this with my dad. He thought his fish oil was harmless. Turns out it was making his blood too thin to handle the aspirin he was taking for his âmildâ heart issue. We cut the fish oil. He hasnât bruised like a grape since. Sometimes the simplest things - like bringing a bag - are the most radical acts of love.
Jamison Kissh
I used to think this was just for old people. Then I started taking 8 meds after my surgery. I didnât realize I was doubling up on ibuprofen - one from my ortho, one from my primary. I was dizzy all day. After the review? Gone. Iâm 42. This isnât just for seniors. Itâs for anyone whoâs not paying attention.
Tony Du bled
My mom used to hide her vitamins in the cookie jar. Said it made her feel like she was âtaking care of herself.â We found 14 different supplements in there. Some expired. One was labeled âfor energyâ - it was just sugar and caffeine. She cried when the pharmacist said she didnât need half of them. Then she smiled. She said, âI didnât know I was pretending to be healthy.â
Art Van Gelder
Let me tell you about my aunt. She took 23 pills a day. She said she was âdoing everything right.â She had a notebook. She had a pill organizer. She had a spreadsheet. She still didnât know she was taking two different versions of the same blood pressure med. One was generic. One was brand. Both said âLisinopril 10mg.â She thought they were different because the pills looked different. The brown bag saved her. She now takes 8. She says she feels like sheâs 60 again, not 82. This isnât a checklist. Itâs a second chance.
Kathryn Weymouth
I work in a clinic, and Iâve seen firsthand how unreliable verbal lists are. One patient swore she wasnât taking any OTC meds. When we asked her to bring her bag, she pulled out three bottles of melatonin, two bottles of glucosamine, and a jar of CBD gummies she got from her yoga instructor. She didnât think they counted. They absolutely do.
Nader Bsyouni
This whole brown bag thing is just performative medicine. You think bringing a bag changes anything? The system is broken. Doctors donât have time. Pharmacists are overworked. This is just a feel-good ritual for people who want to believe theyâre doing something while the real problems - drug pricing, insurance loopholes, corporate greed - stay untouched. Bring your bag. Then go vote for Medicare for All.